Tuesday, October 18, 2011

A Challenge to The Media


In recent years, the “old media” has struggled to come to grips with the brave new world of social networking. Most, if not all, have attempted some foray into the frontier. Well, now I am going to challenge you to do something that goes against your very nature: treat social networks as a truly participatory media, and not “another content distribution pipeline.”

Why? In the race for the Republican nomination leading up to next year's election, there have already been several debates, and watching them makes one thing clear to those of us following along: the few media organizations who organize the debates, set the criteria for inclusion, and devise the polls that are used to define those criteria, wield an enormously disproportionate influence on which candidates are given the chance to appear and to address a national audience. How do we know this? Because today, in the age of social media, candidates can at least get some exposure without the “old media.” As a result, we are able to read the frustrated bloggings, tweets and comments of these “fringe” candidates, who have active campaigns, some level of support, and a real desire to have their voices heard and to be granted the chance to make their case before the American voters.

So what is the challenge? Host a debate, and place the criteria for inclusion solely in the hands of social media. The American public will let you know from whom they would like to hear -- using modern technology, rather than antiquated phone polling.

My proposal is quite simple:
Rule #1: Choose the social media sites and metrics that you will use.
I recommend:
  • Facebook – number of “Likes” on the candidate's page
  • Youtube – number of subscribers to the candidate's channel
  • Twitter – number of followers of the candidate, and
  • Google+ – number of people who have the candidate in their “Circles”

Rule #2: Announce the criteria for inclusion:
  1. You must be a legally qualified and registered candidate for the 2012 Presidential election.
  2. You must contact the hosting media organization to express your desire to debate, and provide the official campaign-approved links to your accounts on the above sites (one per social networking site – if you have multiple pages/accounts on a given social media site, you'll have to pick which one represents you).
  3. The metrics specified in rule one will be summed to determine each candidate's “score,” and candidates with the highest N (8 seems to be the magic number for debates?) scores will be invited to debate.

Now one final interesting thing to think about.. If you're from the “Old Media,” and you're reading this right now, it's an indication of the power of the very same social media that I am challenging you to harness. I'm not a politician, a television personality, syndicated columnist, or a famous pundit. I'm a guy sitting in his den in eastern Washington writing this instead of watching CNN's debate tonight, because the candidates I most wanted to hear from are not included. Now I'm going to post it on a blog, toss it out to Facebook and Twitter, and see if my friends pass it along to their friends until it lands on the desk of somebody at a media outlet that wants to do something truly unique instead of following the rest of the herd.  If you are behind that desk, think hard about this -- only one media outlet gets to be the leader.  There is only one "first."